Connect with us

News

Tribunal Strikes out PDP, Adebutu’s reply on Vote Buying Allegation Against Dapo Abiodun

Published

on

774 Views

The Governorship Election Petition Tribunal sitting in Abeokuta, Ogun State, on Monday struck out the vote buying allegation, levelled against Governor Dapo Abiodun and the All Progressives Congress (APC) by the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) and its governorship candidate, Ladi Adebutu.

Adebutu had dragged Governor Abiodun and the APC to the tribunal challenging their declaration as the winner of the 18, March 2023 governorship election in the state.

But the governor’s lawyers, led by Chief Wole Olanipekun (SAN), in their defence to the petition, made weighty allegations backed up with police report, establishing that Adebutu and the PDP engaged in vote buying during the elections.

On 22 May, 2023, Adebutu and the PDP filed a reply to the defence by Governor Abiodun and the APC, also levelling vote buying allegation against the ruling party.

The Governor’s lawyers, represented by Prof. Taiwo Osipitan (SAN), however, filed an application asking the Tribunal to strike out the Reply in its entirety or in the alternative, to strike out offending paragraphs from that Reply.

Osipitan argued that the Reply filed by Adebutu and PDP contravenes paragraph 16(1) (a & b) of the Electoral Act and the rules of court pleadings.

While ruling on the matter, the Chairman of the Tribunal, Justice H.N. Kunaza, agreed with the submissions by Prof. Osipitan

In the ruling, supported by the other two members; Hon. Justice J.B. Egele and Hon. Justice Sannusi Shehu, the Tribunal overruled Adebutu’s lawyers, led by Chief Goddy Uche (SAN), saying that the application filed by the Governor’s lawyers was not the kind of application that the Constitution requires to be determined at the end of proceedings in judgment.

Relying on relevant provisions of the Constitution, the Tribunal held that only applications that challenge the tribunal’s jurisdiction or the competence of a petition will be deferred till judgment whereas the application filed by Governor Abiodun’s lawyers was not that kind of application.

The Tribunal also held that the Reply by Adebutu and PDP was incompetent for multiple reasons.

The Tribunal identified some paragraphs which contained unnecessary and repetitive allegations, others, which contained arguments and legal conclusions (which are not allowed in replies), and some paragraphs which were an improper expansion of the petition earlier filed.

The Tribunal noted that in their petition, Adebutu and PDP alleged that Governor Abiodun and APC committed corrupt practices during the gubernatorial elections. The Tribunal further noted that vote buying is a specie of corruption and that if PDP and Adebutu truly believed that APC engaged in vote buying, the petitioner ought to have included those allegations in their petition from the start, which they did not do.

The Tribunal noted that if the Reply filed by Adebutu and PDP was permitted, there was a risk to prejudice, surprise, or even shut out Governor Abiodun and APC on the issues raised in that Reply.

The Tribunal denounced Adebutu and the PDP for coming up with the vote-buying allegation only after APC and Governor Abiodun had done same against them.

With this backdrop, the Tribunal unanimously concluded that Governor Abiodun and APC would be prejudiced if the Reply filed by Adebutu and PDP is allowed.

The Tribunal held that when Governor Abiodun and APC filed their defence, they joined issues with Adebutu and PDP; that by joining issues, the parties fixed the dispute; and that it was improper to go outside those issues in the Reply.

The Tribunal also found that it was unnecessary to file a Reply in the circumstance, as held in several decisions of the Supreme Court and the Appeal Court.

The Reply was accordingly struck out.

With this ruling, only the allegation of vote buying made by Governor Abiodun and APC against Adebutu and the PDP would be entertained by the tribunal.

Jelili Owonikoko (SAN), represented INEC, while the APC team was led by Chief Onyeazu Ikpeazu (SAN).

It would be recalled that Adebutu and PDP leaders in Ogun State have been charged for the offence of vote buying by the Federal Government, a situation that has led to Adebutu being a fugitive to the law.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

News

ESUT to be renamed after Jim Nwobodo – Mbah

… there is a legal process to follow. ESUT was established by law, and changing its name would require the appropriate legislative steps and engagement with relevant stakeholders.

Published

on

By

42 Views

Governor of Enugu State, Dr. Peter Mbah, has unveiled plans to rename the Enugu State University of Science and Technology (ESUT) after a Second Republic Governor of old Anambra State, Senator Jim Nwobodo.

Mbah made this known during the 3rd Distinguished Personality Lecture of the university delivered by Nwobodo at the Barr. Peter Ndubuisi Mbah Multipurpose Auditorium, ESUT, Enugu, on Thursday.

He said the idea, which was first suggested by the ESUT Alumni Association, was in tandem with his thoughts, describing it as a fitting tribute to the elder statesman, who founded the institution in 1980.

The Governor emphasised that the brainchild of the ex-governor had played a critical role in the human capital development of not just Enugu State, but also the old Anambra State and Nigeria as a whole.

He, however, said that there is a legal process to follow. ESUT was established by law, and changing its name would require the appropriate legislative steps and engagement with relevant stakeholders.

“I intend to begin those engagements and work with the institutions concerned to advance the proposal through the proper process,” he said.

Continue Reading

News

South Africans Begin Another ‘Operations Flush Out Nigerians’ Protest

Fani-Kayode described those behind xenophobic attacks as a tiny minority who should not be allowed to define the character of the country’s population.

Published

on

By

85 Views

Nigeria’s High Commissioner to South Africa, Femi Fani-Kayode, is sweating to protect Nigerians and Nigeria’s image as protesters, operating under the March and March movement launched a fresh anti-Nigerian campaign, ” The state must ban Nigerians from South Africa. They must ban Nigerians until they stop selling drugs to our people. The rest of Africa, we are fine, but we do not want Nigerians in South Africa anymore. That is what we are saying.”

The protesters on Wednesday led by the group’s leader, Jacinta Ngobese-Zuma, took a particularly confrontational turn in Sunnyside, a Pretoria suburb popularly associated with a sizeable Nigerian community and sometimes described as ‘Little Lagos.

They specifically accused Nigerians of engaging in drug trafficking and contributing to social problems in South African communities.

The demonstration, .Challenging Nigerian residents to explain their presence and influence in the neighbourhood, Ngobese-Zuma questioned how the area acquired the nickname.

“I am being told here that we’ve entered Sunnyside, the home of Nigerians. I am inviting Nigerians to come out, let’s talk to each other. We want to know who gave you this place and called it Nigeria. Who gave you permission to call this place Lagos or whatever you call it?” she asked.She further questioned who had authorised Nigerians to identify parts of South African territory with their home country.

The remarks point to the increasingly hostile rhetoric directed at the immigrant community.

Ngobese-Zuma described the convention as “not sustainable and not feasible”.

She alleged that the presence of migrants was placing additional pressure on public resources and aggravating the frustrations of South African citizens.

The movement said it was taking its grievances to the Department of Home Affairs, where it intended to formally present its demands for tougher immigration controls, restrictions on refugee admissions and accelerated deportation of undocumented foreign nationals.

For his part, the group’s legal representative, Xolani Zuma, went further by demanding an outright prohibition on Nigerians entering South Africa.

The latest demonstration comes amid growing strain in relations between Nigeria and South Africa over recurring xenophobic hostility, the safety of Nigerian nationals and disagreements surrounding the diplomatic representation of both countries.

Only last week, Fani-Kayode, and the South African Presidency were involved in a diplomatic exchange following the exclusion of his prepared speech during the presentation of his credentials.

Fani-Kayode had described the omission as disrespectful to Nigeria.

Although he subsequently said the disagreement had been resolved following the intervention of South African President Cyril Ramaphosa and an invitation from the country’s Department of International Relations and Cooperation.

The envoy also disclosed that he had begun addressing concerns affecting Nigerians in South Africa since assuming office.

Fani-Kayode described those behind xenophobic attacks as a tiny minority who should not be allowed to define the character of the country’s population.

He maintained that the majority of South Africans were decent and accommodating.

He expressed confidence that the two countries could overcome their differences without severing longstanding diplomatic relations.

However, Fani-Kayode had warned that patience was running thin within Nigeria’s corridors of power over repeated attacks on its citizens.He insisted that the country would not abandon its nationals to xenophobic violence.

Continue Reading

News

Lockdown on Lagos/Ibadan highway [PHOTOS] motorists spend whole day in traffic

Published

on

By

126 Views
Traffic

Traffic

Traffic
Continue Reading

Trending